Skip to main content

Managed IT vs. break-fix.

Two completely different ways to handle your business technology, with very different cost structures, response times, and risk profiles. Here's the breakdown so you can decide which fits your operation.

The 30-second version

Break-fix means you call IT when something is broken, pay by the hour, and get back to work. There's no monthly fee. That sounds great until you do the math on what "broken" costs over a year.

Managed IT means you pay a flat monthly fee and the MSP keeps your environment monitored, patched, backed up, and supported continuously, so fewer things break in the first place.

For a 5-person business, the rough math: break-fix runs $9,000 to $22,000/year all-in (hourly fees + downtime + the one bad ransomware month). Managed IT runs $6,000 to $12,000/year with predictable cost and dramatically lower downtime risk.

Side-by-side comparison

Feature Managed IT Break-fix
Cost structure Flat monthly per-user fee. Predictable budget line item. Hourly billing ($150 to $250/hr). Unpredictable spikes when things go wrong.
Response time Priority business-hours response from someone who knows your environment; response targets are written into your agreement. Whenever the technician has time. Often hours or days.
Monitoring & alerting ✓ 24/7 endpoint & network monitoring ✗ None. You discover problems after they're problems.
Patch management ✓ Automated, scheduled, reported on monthly ✗ Whenever you remember (or don't)
Backup & restore testing ✓ Verified restores (quarterly on ProperCare, monthly on ProperShield) ~ Backup software exists but rarely tested
Cybersecurity ✓ EDR, MFA, phishing training, security audits ✗ Mostly reactive: fix breaches after they happen
Cyber-insurance compliance ✓ Documented controls, ready for your carrier's questionnaire ✗ Likely fails policy requirements; claims may be denied
Vendor relationship One known person who knows your environment Whoever's available, often someone new each time
Documentation ✓ Network maps, account inventory, vendor logins maintained ✗ Usually nothing written down
Total annual cost (5-person business) $6,000 to $12,000 $9,000 to $22,000+
Figures are typical Treasure Valley ranges, 2026; your environment may vary.

The cost math

The break-fix advertised rate is misleading on its own. The annual cost includes hourly fees plus downtime plus the one bad month when something serious happens. Here's the typical 5-person small business:

Break-fix (Year 1)

8 hrs/mo support × $200/hr × 12: $19,200
After-hours emergency × 2: $1,200
Downtime (avg 6 hrs/mo @ $400/hr): $28,800
Risk: one ransomware event: $30K to $200K+
Typical realized: $25K to $50K+

Managed IT (Year 1)

5 users × $150/mo × 12: $9,000
After-hours emergency: $250/hr best-effort (ProperShield includes 2 incidents a month)
Downtime: ~1 hr/mo (proactive monitoring)
Ransomware risk: dramatically reduced
Typical realized: $9K to $12K

The hidden cost of break-fix: the technician you call has no context about your environment. Every visit starts with "what's the password?" and "where's the server?" You're billed at $200/hr while they figure it out. With managed IT, the same person already knows your setup.

Want the dollar number for your team? The downtime cost calculator plugs in your team size and average hourly value, then shows what a typical outage costs. That's the number most break-fix users have never put on paper.

Open the downtime calculator Download the pricing PDF

When break-fix makes sense.

Not always wrong. Break-fix can be reasonable when:

  • You're a 1 to 2 person operation with little IT footprint (no servers, no compliance, no card-on-file payments)
  • You're using nothing but standard SaaS tools that vendors support directly (M365, Google Workspace, QuickBooks Online)
  • You have someone internal who's genuinely IT-capable for routine issues
  • You don't store customer payment data or PHI that triggers compliance requirements

If those four boxes all check, break-fix can work fine. Budget $1,500 to $3,000 a year for the inevitable issues.

When you almost certainly need managed IT.

Managed IT becomes the obviously right answer when any of these are true:

  • You run dispatch software (ServiceTitan, Housecall Pro, Jobber) and downtime kills service calls
  • You take card-on-file payments → PCI compliance applies
  • You have any cyber-insurance policy → your carrier likely requires MFA, EDR, verified backups
  • You do work for healthcare facilities → HIPAA may apply (for example, through a business associate agreement)
  • You have 5+ employees with email and shared file access
  • You can't afford 4+ hours of "system down" without losing money

Bottom line: if your business depends on IT to dispatch jobs, take payments, or store customer data, break-fix is borrowing against a future bad month. A serious outage or ransomware event can get expensive fast. Managed IT gives you a predictable monthly number and reduces preventable risk. If you are weighing a full-time hire instead, the in-house vs. managed IT cost math runs the same numbers for a salaried IT person.

What I do differently.

My ProperStart, ProperCare, and ProperShield tiers run $100 to $200 per user, with a 30-day satisfaction guarantee on new managed IT plans. The structure is the same as any good MSP. What's different is that I'm the one on the other end of the line. You get my direct number, with no ticket queue and no junior tech who's never seen your environment. I've been in IT support and administration roles since 2022, and I'm a USAF veteran with a CompTIA Security+ certification.

Want the side-by-side applied to your specific environment? The free 15-minute IT review covers that. Bring your current break-fix invoices and I'll do the math on what managed IT would cost vs. what you're spending now.

Common questions

On paper, yes, until something breaks. The math flips the first time you have a full day of downtime, a ransomware incident, or a failed backup. Break-fix means no monitoring, no patching, no verified backup, no cyber-insurance compliance. You're paying less monthly and a lot more per incident.
That's a common path. The issue is that by the time you've decided to switch, the environment is usually messy: undocumented, unpatched, no clean backups. Onboarding takes longer and costs more than starting clean. It's doable, but not free.
Increasingly, no. Most carriers now require documented MFA, EDR, verified backups, and security awareness training to pay a claim. Break-fix doesn't produce that documentation. If you file a claim and can't show the controls were in place, the claim can be denied.
Solo operator with no employees, no customer data, no compliance pressure, and tolerance for being your own IT. Or a project-only need (one website build, one office move). For anyone with employees, customer data, or revenue tied to systems being online, break-fix is gambling.

Get the math for your business.

15-minute call. Bring your last 3 break-fix invoices. I'll calculate your realized hourly spend and what a managed plan would cost, apples to apples. No pitch.

Request a call back