Skip to main content

Should you hire an IT person or use a managed IT service?

Cost math built for Boise small businesses with 5 to 75 employees. By the time you finish reading, you'll know which model fits your business and your budget. I'll cover loaded salary numbers, breakeven analysis, the hybrid model, and the tradeoffs.

Boise salary data Transparent MSP pricing Breakeven analysis Tradeoffs 5-question quiz

Both models work. Which one fits you depends on three things.

Hiring your own IT person and outsourcing to a managed IT service are both legitimate strategies. Plenty of profitable Idaho businesses run each model successfully. The right answer for your business depends on three things: your size, your budget, and how much downtime risk you can absorb without losing money.

What you usually get from other "in-house vs. MSP" pages is marketing copy disguised as a comparison. This page does the math out loud: Boise salary data from the BLS, fully-loaded employment costs, transparent Idaho Proper IT pricing, and the breakeven point where in-house starts to make sense.

The short version: below ~50 users, managed IT is almost always 2 to 3x cheaper than hiring. Above ~70 to 75 users, in-house can pencil out. Between those numbers, it comes down to specifics: what work needs to happen, how much downtime you can tolerate, and whether you want to be in the IT-hiring business.

Cost of an in-house IT person (Boise, 2026)

The number an owner usually quotes ("I can hire an IT guy for $70k") is the base salary. That's not the cost of the employee. The actual cost is base plus payroll taxes, healthcare, retirement match, workers comp, PTO, and tools. Numbers below use U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics data for "Network and Computer Systems Administrators," geo-adjusted to the Boise metro and reflecting typical Treasure Valley ranges. Specialty roles like security engineer, cloud architect, or deep M365 admin push higher.

Bottom line: A fully-loaded mid-level in-house IT hire in Boise runs roughly $110,000 to $145,000 per year once you add tools and benefits. That's the number to compare against.

The cost stack

Junior IT admin base salary$55,000 to $72,000 (Boise BLS, 2024 data adjusted forward). Handles tickets, basic helpdesk, account provisioning. Limited security depth.
Mid-level sysadmin base$75,000 to $95,000. Can manage M365, networks, backups, and respond to most incidents without a senior backstop.
Loaded cost multiplierRoughly 1.3 to 1.4x base. Payroll taxes, health insurance, 401(k) match, workers comp, PTO. A $90k base becomes ~$117k to $126k.
Tools & licenses$5,000 to $12,000/year. RMM platform, ticketing system, basic security tooling, training subscriptions. A solo IT person still needs the same software stack an MSP runs.
Coverage gap + turnover riskOne person works ~2,080 hours/yr. PTO, sick days, and weekends mean no coverage when they're out. Add recruiter fees (15 to 25% of base) and 60 to 90 days of ramp if they quit.

Cost of Idaho Proper IT (transparent)

Per-user, per-month pricing published on the website. No "call for quote" games. Multiply users by tier and you have the annual.

ProperStart

"Your safety net."

$100

per user / month

15 users → $18,000/yr
30 users → $36,000/yr
50 users → $60,000/yr
✓ 24/7 monitoring
✓ EDR, MFA, daily backup
✓ Helpdesk Mon to Fri
Most Common

ProperCare

"Your IT department."

$150

per user / month

15 users → $27,000/yr
30 users → $54,000/yr
50 users → $90,000/yr
✓ Patching + M365 admin
✓ Phishing training
✓ Quarterly business review

ProperShield

"Maximum protection."

$200

per user / month

15 users → $36,000/yr
30 users → $72,000/yr
50 users → $120,000/yr
✓ Controls mapped to your compliance framework
✓ Monthly restore testing
✓ Cyber-insurance alignment

What's included: 24/7 monitoring, helpdesk, M365 administration, patching, phishing-awareness training, quarterly reviews, and quarterly restore testing. A smaller PTO gap, because the environment is documented and monitored automatically. There's no quitting and no 60-day rehire ramp six months later. Documented, monitored systems carry the work instead of one person's memory.

Side-by-side comparison

In-house IT (one mid-level admin) vs. Idaho Proper IT ProperCare. Numbers are annual fully-loaded.

Factor In-House IT (1 mid-level admin) Idaho Proper IT (ProperCare)
Annual cost (15 users)$110,000 to $145,000$27,000
Annual cost (30 users)$110,000 to $145,000$54,000
Annual cost (50 users)$110,000 to $145,000$90,000
Coverage hours~40 hr/wk (one person)24/7 monitoring + business-hour helpdesk
PTO & sick gapNo IT until they returnNone. Documented environment + 24/7 monitoring (one-person shop, not a bench of techs)
Ramp-up time60 to 90 days from offer to productive1 to 2 weeks onboarding
Specialized skillsOne person, broad knowledge, depth variesSpecialist depth + I'm Sec+ certified
Quits & leaves you strandedAverage IT tenure is shortN/A (contracted service)
Documentation maintainedOften not. One person, no timeRequired and documented
Cyber-insurance complianceDepends on the individual hireDocumented controls; full compliance documentation on ProperShield

In-house cost is a flat range because one admin costs roughly the same whether they support 15 users or 50. That's the structural problem.

When does in-house make sense?

The math is straightforward. ProperCare is $150/user/month, which is $1,800 per user per year. A fully-loaded mid-level in-house IT person is roughly $130,000/year. Divide $130,000 by $1,800 and you get the breakeven user count.

$130,000 ÷ $1,800 = ~72 users

At roughly 70 to 75 users, the cost of one in-house IT person equals the cost of ProperCare. Above that, in-house can be cheaper on the spreadsheet, though you take on the management overhead, hiring risk, and PTO gap.

For most businesses below 50 employees, managed IT is 2 to 3x cheaper than hiring in-house. You also get 24/7 automated monitoring, a smaller PTO gap, and documented compliance. Caveats that shift the math: proprietary software that needs constant babysitting, a regulated industry that requires a named on-site security officer, or heavy on-site presence (manufacturing floor, multi-clinic healthcare) push the breakeven down. Standard user support, M365, security, and infrastructure work pushes it up.

The underrated option: one internal person + an MSP

For businesses that need a hands-on body in the building but don't need a full senior IT department.

Plenty of small businesses run a hybrid model: one internal "IT-and-everything-else" person who handles day-to-day user requests, hardware, onboarding, and physical site work. That person is backed by an MSP for depth on security, M365, networking, backups, and after-hours coverage.

~$60,000 base internal hire (junior generalist, fully loaded ~$78k)
+ ~$1,000/mo partial-coverage managed IT
= ~$90,000/year total

You get a person on-site who knows everyone's name, plus a senior-level partner in your corner for the work the junior shouldn't be doing alone: security, compliance, complex M365, network architecture. I support this hybrid for businesses that want it; the MSP's role is to backstop the internal hire, not compete with them.

What I'll tell you out loud

Not every business should hire Idaho Proper IT.

In-house wins when

You have 75+ users. You have constant on-site IT needs (manufacturing, multi-site healthcare, dense lab environments). You're in a regulated industry that requires a named, full-time security officer. You have proprietary internal software that requires deep, dedicated knowledge.

2

Managed IT wins when

You have under 50 users. You want predictable monthly cost without payroll headaches. You don't want to be in the IT-hiring business. You want 24/7 monitoring you don't have to staff. You'd rather pay for an outcome than for a chair to be filled.

3

Either way, you need

A written cybersecurity plan. Documented backups with quarterly restore tests. 24/7 monitoring (more than antivirus). MFA on every account that touches business data. A documented incident response plan. These are non-negotiable in 2026, both for cyber insurance and for staying in business.

4

Don't pick on price alone

Cheaper IT that doesn't document, doesn't patch, and doesn't restore-test is more expensive than expensive IT that does. The cost question to ask is "what does an outage, a ransomware event, or a denied insurance claim cost?"

5 questions. Count your yes answers.

If you answer "yes" to 3 or more, managed IT is the better fit for your business right now.

1

Do you have under 50 employees?

Below 50, the breakeven math almost always favors managed IT. A flat per-user rate scales with you instead of a fixed salary that's the same whether you have 12 users or 48.

2

Are you tired of being the IT person?

If "the network's down" still ends up on the owner's phone, you're paying owner-rate hours for IT work. That's the most expensive labor in the company.

3

Do you need 24/7 monitoring?

A single in-house hire works ~40 hours a week. The other 128 hours, your environment is unwatched. Ransomware does not respect business hours.

4

Have you ever lost data?

Lost a file, an inbox, a server? Couldn't recover from a backup because nobody had tested it? You need a documented backup-and-restore program, audited regularly. That's part of managed IT by default.

5

Asked "are we secure?" and gotten a vague answer?

"I think so" or "we have antivirus" is not an answer. A documented program tells you what's protected, monitored, and patched. It also tells you what your gaps are.

3 or more "yes" answers? Managed IT is the better fit for your business right now. Request a call back and I'll run the math on your specific user count, current setup, and the gaps that matter most.

Want to run the math on your specific situation?

Free 15-minute call with me. We'll plug in your user count, your current setup, and your coverage needs, and you'll walk away with a clear picture of what each model would cost your business. No sales pitch and no obligation.

Request a Call Back Call (208) 918-0636

There's no obligation and no sales script. If hiring is the right answer for you, I'll tell you that out loud.

Related pages

Industry-specific decision pages

If you already know what kind of business you run, jump straight to the page built for you.

IT for Boise Law Firms →
ABA-aligned cybersecurity, litigation-hold-friendly backups
IT for Medical & Dental Practices →
HIPAA-aligned, BAA included, EHR uptime
Data Backup & Recovery →
3-2-1, restore testing, ransomware-resistant storage
All managed IT plans →
Plan comparisons, what's included, onboarding