WordPress, Wix, or a Custom Site? What Actually Makes Sense for a Boise Small Business

An honest comparison of WordPress, Wix/Squarespace, and a hand-built site for a Boise small business, including the maintenance and security costs nobody mentions up front.

Reviewed by Joey Garcia · CompTIA Security+ · USAF Veteran · September 14, 2026

The question I get most often

"Should I just do it on Wix?" Fair question. I'll give you the honest version, including where the DIY builders are the right call.

Wix and Squarespace

Good for: A side business, a one-page site you'll update yourself, a project where you need something live this weekend.

What nobody tells you: The monthly price climbs once you need a real domain, remove their branding, and add forms or booking. By the time you have the features a business needs, you're paying a real monthly fee and doing all the work yourself, and there's only so much you can do about speed from inside a builder.

When it stops working: The moment you want something the template doesn't do. Custom quote forms, a service-area page structure that ranks, integrating with your dispatch software. You hit a wall and the answer is "rebuild."

WordPress

Good for: Content-heavy sites, blogs, anything where a lot of people need to log in and edit.

What nobody tells you: WordPress isn't bad, but a neglected WordPress site is a common way small-business sites get compromised: the site has 23 plugins, none have been updated since 2023, and the hosting was the cheapest option. A WordPress site needs someone patching it every week. If nobody's doing that, it's a liability. I've written about what that looks like from the security side .

Real cost: Hosting, a theme, plugins, and either your time or someone's invoice for updates. Add it up before you assume it's the cheap option.

A hand-built site (what I do)

Good for: A business that wants a site that loads fast, ranks locally, and doesn't need babysitting.

What it is: Clean HTML and CSS, no page builder, no plugin stack to keep patched. Far less to hack, because there's no admin panel or plugin stack to break into. It's fast on a phone because there's nothing extra in the way.

The tradeoff: You don't log in and drag things around. You text me and I make the change. For most trades and service businesses, that's actually a plus. They didn't want to be webmasters anyway.

Cost: $99 a month , flat. Hosting, SSL, backups, security, reasonable edits, and a free domain are all included. Setup is $499, waived with a 12-month term. With a builder you pay monthly and do the work; here you pay monthly and don't.

Quick decision guide

  • Need it live this weekend, will update it yourself, don't care much about ranking → Wix/Squarespace.
  • Publishing a lot of content, have someone who'll keep it patched → WordPress.
  • Want calls from Google, don't want to think about it, want one person to text → custom, on a plan.

One more thing about "free" site builders

The site your Google Business profile or your POS system gave you for free is not a website. It's a placeholder they own. If you ever leave that platform, it's gone. Own your domain and own your site.

Questions about your situation? Ask me . I'll tell you if Wix is fine for you.

About Joey Garcia

USAF Veteran CompTIA Security+ Boise, ID

Joey Garcia is the founder of Idaho Proper IT, a Boise-area technology company serving trades, professional offices, and other small businesses. He served in the U.S. Air Force at Mountain Home AFB, holds a CompTIA Security+ certification, and has worked in IT support and administration roles since 2022. Idaho Proper IT is intentionally personal: Joey does the work himself, without handing you to a junior technician you have never met.

📞 (208) 918-0636 Free IT health check →

Share this article:

Need Help With This? Let's Talk.

Talk directly with Joey about your website, lead follow-up, and a free custom homepage mockup. Start with a free 15-minute call.